Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Father asks for $400K in school fees refund
That's Just Not Right! > KVL's Smart Arses > World News
~vjay~
QUOTE
A FATHER whose twin sons flunked their final exams is demanding an elite private school repay up to $400,000 in fees.

Victorian Steven Weybury, unhappy with his sons' VCE results, has challenged Brighton Grammar to refund the money spent educating his twins from kindergarten to year 12.

He has alleged his boys were humiliated by their VCE results.

Mr Weybury - a partner in a city law firm - claims he warned the school that his boys were headed for academic disaster in their final year and attempted to remove them at the end of year 11.

But school bosses persuaded him to let the boys stay on and assured him that they could cope emotionally and academically, he claims.

"The boys did not successfully complete year 12 in any respect," court documents allege.

"The boys obtained placements in courses of a type which did not require year 12 attendance."

Mr Weybury has sought a refund of fees paid for the boys between 1994 and 2007, as well as damages and legal costs.

"The plaintiff paid fees to (the school) for a total of 28 years in an amount of the region of $400,000," court documents allege.

"The lack of achievement of the boys in all areas considered important . . . confirms that the payment of fees were (sic) excessive and unnecessary."

Mr Weybury has alleged his sons suffered psychological and emotional harm arising during their VCE year.

In a defence filed with the court, lawyers for Brighton Grammar said the school had provided special assistance to the boys throughout their schooling.

The boys were also given extra language and maths classes and speech therapy in primary school years, according to the school.

The school also claimed in its defence that each boy completed VCE and each was offered and accepted a place in a tertiary course of his choice.


Stupid source



I'd say it was more a case of a father having too high expectations and then feeling humiliated himeself due to wasting money on private school for average marks, what a twit.
shirizaki
Yeah I'd need to hear more. Did he think to get his sons tutors? Because I'd like to think a man who knows law should know that schools that charge 200K per child are only getting the name of the school on the diploma, not a real education.
CaptainPony
QUOTE(~vjay~ @ Mar 15 2008, 04:48 PM) *
QUOTE
Mr Weybury - a partner in a city law firm - claims he warned the school that his boys were headed for academic disaster in their final year and attempted to remove them at the end of year 11.

But school bosses persuaded him to let the boys stay on and assured him that they could cope emotionally and academically, he claims.


If he can prove that, whether it's in writing or whatever, I say he has the win right there.

I'm on the father's side here.
In my experience 99% of teachers are incompetent.
Having met many ed students over the last 4 years I'd say that's not about to change.

I understand that students have different mental abilities, motivations, etc. that contribute to their grades but there has to be some responsibility on the school, especially if they're giving guarantees.
nun
The school persuaded him to keep his kids in residence when he was about to remove them. I think that displays a certain amount of culpability. Not the entierty of the tuition, but probably something.

shirizaki
Well he could argue for that year's tuition plus maybe 1/4 more for pain and suffering.
~vjay~
I disagree. The last part says they passed re:
QUOTE
The school also claimed in its defence that each boy completed VCE and each was offered and accepted a place in a tertiary course of his choice.
which says to me that they passed, they just didn't get "high" grades which to me sounds like Mr Lawyer man wanted them to score in the top level and they didn't...
Ryanella
You can't send retards to private schools and expect them to become unretarded just because you spent 400k.

Thats
just
Retarded.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.